Craigslist Cars & Trucks for Sale by Owner in Rochester, NY
Looking for a used car in Rochester? Below are live Craigslist listings for cars and trucks in the Rochester area, plus everything you need to buy safely from a private seller in New York. Want more choice? Use the nationwide search to compare prices in every Craigslist city at once.
Cars for sale by owner in Rochester
Live results from Craigslist listings nationwide. Click a listing to open the original ad.
Loading listings…
Search by make in Rochester
- Used Ford
- Used Chevrolet
- Used Toyota
- Used Honda
- Used Nissan
- Used Jeep
- Used Dodge
- Used GMC
- Used Subaru
- Used Hyundai
- Used Kia
- Used BMW
How to buy a used car from a private seller in Rochester
- Compare prices. Look at several listings with similar year and mileage, in Rochester and in nearby cities, to know what a fair price is.
- Ask for the VIN before you meet, and run a vehicle history report to check for accidents, flood damage and odometer issues.
- Meet safely in a public place, ideally a police "safe exchange" zone, during the day.
- Inspect and test drive. Use our inspection checklist, and for any car over a few thousand dollars, pay a local mechanic for a pre-purchase inspection.
- Check the paperwork. The name on the title must match the seller's ID, with no lien listed and a VIN that matches the car.
- Pay safely with a cashier's check or at the seller's bank. Never wire money or pay with gift cards — read how to avoid Craigslist car scams.
- Transfer the title through the New York State DMV.
Other Craigslist car markets in New York
- New York City
- Brooklyn
- Queens
- Long Island
- Buffalo
- Syracuse
- Albany
- Yonkers
- Ithaca
- Binghamton
- Utica
- Hudson Valley
- All of New York
Frequently asked questions
Where can I find cars for sale by owner in Rochester?
Craigslist is the largest source of private-party car listings in Rochester. CraigsCars shows live Rochester listings on this page and lets you search every other Craigslist city at once if you are willing to travel for the right car.
Where should I meet a Craigslist car seller in Rochester?
Meet in daylight in a busy public place. Many police departments offer designated "safe exchange" zones in their parking lots — call the local non-emergency number to ask. Bring a friend and never carry large amounts of cash to a first viewing.
How do I transfer a car title in Rochester, NY?
Title transfers in New York are handled by the New York State DMV. Bring the signed title, a bill of sale, your ID and proof of insurance.